| Charles Jones |  McKendree | Portal | — | — |
| Dyren Brown |  Saint Martin's |  Southern Wesleyan | — | — |
| Bronson Smith |  Anderson |  Arkansas Tech | — | — |
| Nate Kingz |  Westmont |  Oregon State | — | — |
| Joel Day |  Thomas More | Portal | — | — |
| Noah Pedelty | Thomas More | Portal | — | — |
| Kort Justice | Thomas More | Portal | — | — |
| Avante Lederer |  Miles | Portal | — | — |
| David Okpara | Anderson |  Cedarville | — | — |
| Logan Stempniak |  Alaska |  Bellevue College | — | — |
| R.J. Bell |  Erskine | Portal | — | — |
| Malik Bryant |  Barton |  Flagler | — | — |
| Ameil Malone |  Johnson C. Smith |  Georgia Southwestern | Power Forward | Jr |
| Nasir Brown |  Lincoln (PA) |  Mansfield | Shooting Guard | Sr |
| Scotty Draud |  Kentucky Wesleyan | Thomas More | Shooting Guard | Sr |
| Kevin Perry |  Albany State | Portal | — | — |
| Manny Hill |  Notre Dame (OH) |  Cleveland State | Point Guard | Sr |
| Ja'Von Anderson |  Francis Marion | Portal | — | — |
| Donald Coats |  Missouri Southern |  Emporia State | — | — |
| Lunden Cook |  Roosevelt | Portal | — | — |
| Ryan Wohlschlegel | Roosevelt | Prince George's Community College | — | — |
| Jamal Briscoe |  Fresno Pacific | Portal | Point Guard | — |
| Paul Hosey |  Young Harris | Portal | — | — |
| Michael Sampson | Notre Dame (OH) | Portal | — | — |
| John Godinez | Notre Dame (OH) | Portal | — | — |
| Parker Rothery |  Tusculum | Portal | — | — |
| Kenneth Hodges |  UNC Pembroke | Portal | — | — |
| Elijah Muehler | Barton | Portal | — | — |
| DeSean Munson |  Northwood | Portal | — | — |
| C.J. Penha, Jr. |  Trevecca Nazarene | Portal | — | — |
| J’Son Brooks |  King | Portal | — | — |
| Josh Grider |  West Virginia Wesleyan | Portal | — | — |
| Malik Kelly |  Columbus State | Portal | — | — |
| John Bailey |  Benedict | Portal | — | — |
| Jaelin Johnson |  Fairmont State |  Glenville State | — | — |
| Jay Shropshire |  Shorter | Portal | — | — |
| Cal Reed | Tusculum | Portal | — | — |
| Conor Jeffery |  Bridgeport | Portal | — | — |
| Jalen Brown |  Tiffin | Portal | — | — |
| M.J. Foust | King |  Chadron State | — | — |
| Brennan Weller | Arkansas Tech | Portal | Small Forward | — |
| Tommy Williams | Glenville State | Fairmont State | Point Guard | — |
| Miguel Williams | Trevecca Nazarene | Portal | — | — |
| Sihr Sumner | Tiffin | Portal | — | — |
| Sean Tony Hauser |  St. Augustine's |  Fayetteville State | — | — |
| Kendale Chambers, Jr. | Shorter | Portal | — | — |
| Julio Pascual |  Bluefield State | Portal | — | — |
| Jalen Edwards | Erskine | Portal | — | — |
| Ephraim Butler | Fayetteville State | Portal | — | — |
| Judah Jordan |  Mississippi College | Portal | — | — |
